Rorcal – “Mahre”

There are albums that immediately draw you in, albums that take a little convincing, and then there are albums that leave you wondering whether you have made a terrible mistake before eventually revealing something quite extraordinary.

Rorcal‘s “Mahre” firmly belongs in that third category.

I approached this release with considerable scepticism. Experimental atmospheric progressive black metal was not exactly a genre I had been enthusiastically exploring, and the extraordinarily prolonged instrumental introduction to “Movement I” did very little to reassure me that I was about to have a particularly enjoyable experience.

Frankly, I was beginning to wonder what I had let myself in for.

The mix was not helping either. Something about the balance felt distinctly uncomfortable, and not necessarily in the way that experimental extreme metal is supposed to make you uncomfortable.

And then the vocals arrived.

Everything changed.

Suddenly, what had initially felt like a rather laborious exercise in atmospheric experimentation became something altogether more compelling. Yonni Chapatte‘s extraordinary vocal performance introduced the darkness, weight and emotional violence that the composition had been crying out for.
I went from sceptic to genuinely curious potential fan in a matter of moments.

Hailing from Geneva, Switzerland, Rorcal have spent two decades exploring the darker corners of extreme music, combining black metal, doom, sludge, drone and industrial experimentation into something that defies comfortable categorisation.

“Mahre” takes this approach into deeply unsettling territory through a concept in which nightmares become infectious, spreading from one sleeping mind to another until the distinction between reality and psychological torment becomes impossible to recognise.
Five movements, approximately forty minutes, and very little interest in making the listener comfortable.
By the time “Movement II” begins, I am hooked.

The extraordinary thing about this album is the anticipation it generates. Every change in rhythm, every evolving guitar passage and every shift in atmosphere leaves you wondering where the music will take you next.
There is an intelligence to the composition that demands attention. Rorcal are not simply throwing discordant sounds together and calling the result experimental. There is a genuine sense of direction, even when that direction appears to lead somewhere profoundly unpleasant.
The vocals remain an absolute highlight, adding a menacing physical presence to music that might otherwise risk disappearing into its own atmospheric ambitions.

But there is a problem. The drums.

Let me be absolutely clear. The drumming itself is excellent. The musicianship is not in question. It is the placement of the drums within the mix that repeatedly distracts me from what is otherwise an exceptional musical experience.
Rather than sitting comfortably within the surrounding instrumentation, the drums often appear to occupy an entirely different sonic space. And unfortunately, “Movement III” makes this particularly apparent.

This is an extraordinary composition. The band create an almost unbearable sense of existential dread, building tension through oppressive instrumentation, carefully controlled dynamics and an atmosphere that becomes increasingly suffocating. It is uncomfortable listening, and deliberately so. But the drums seem to sit above everything else, almost as though the rest of the music has been added around them as an afterthought.

I find myself listening to the production rather than surrendering to the music, which is particularly frustrating when the composition is this accomplished. There is an important distinction between a deliberately abrasive mix and one that draws attention away from the emotional experience. For me, “Movement III” occasionally crosses that line.

“Movement IV” changes the atmosphere again. Here, Rorcal move towards more recognisable black-metal territory, allowing their considerable musical capabilities to emerge through increasingly aggressive passages. The musicianship is exceptional. The transition feels entirely justified by everything that has come before it, and the band demonstrate that beneath all the experimentation lies a group of extremely accomplished extreme-metal musicians. Interestingly, the drums seem better integrated into the mix.

Whether this represents a genuine change in production balance or simply my ears becoming accustomed to the earlier presentation is difficult to determine. Either way, I find myself considerably less distracted and much more engaged. There is, however, another curious production decision.

During the latter stages of “Movement IV”, occasional moments of feedback become noticeable. Feedback can be an enormously effective creative tool, particularly in music that deliberately embraces noise, dissonance and psychological discomfort. Here, though, I struggle to understand what it contributes. If deliberate, I would question the artistic decision. If accidental, I am surprised it survived the final mixing process. Neither possibility seriously undermines the composition, but both reinforce my feeling that the production choices are not always serving the remarkable music particularly well.

“Movement V” brings everything towards its conclusion. After the intensity and climactic aggression of the preceding movement, there is a sense of the entire experience beginning to resolve itself, although Rorcal are hardly interested in offering anything as reassuring as a conventional happy ending. The atmosphere remains deeply disturbing, but the musical journey now feels complete. And the drums? They sound considerably better to my ears. There is greater cohesion between the percussion and the surrounding instruments, allowing the music to deliver its emotional impact without the distractions that occasionally troubled the earlier movements. By the conclusion, I am left with an interesting dilemma. I have just experienced an extraordinarily imaginative, ambitious and thoroughly compelling piece of extreme music. An album that initially tested my patience has completely won me over. Yet I cannot ignore the production decisions that repeatedly prevented me from becoming entirely immersed in the experience.

“Mahre” is not an album for casual listening. It requires patience, concentration and a willingness to engage with music that actively challenges conventional expectations. But that commitment is richly rewarded. What impresses me most is how effectively Rorcal turn musical composition into psychological storytelling. The gradual escalation, crushing atmosphere and astonishing vocals create an experience that feels far greater than the sum of its individual movements. The production occasionally gets in the way, but the underlying artistry is undeniable. And perhaps that is the greatest compliment I can offer.

Despite my reservations about the mix, despite that intimidating introduction, and despite moments when I desperately wanted the drums to find a more comfortable place amongst the other instruments, I absolutely want to experience this album again. In fact, “Mahre” has already earned a place in my CD collection. Not bad for a record I was initially worried I might struggle to finish. Rorcal have converted a sceptic into a fan.

Now, if someone could just have another look at those drums…

 

Rating: 8/10
Release Date: 25th September 2026 (digital); 9th October 2026 (physical)
Label: Humus Records

Writer: Andy

Tracklist:

  1. Movement I
  2. Movement II
  3. Movement III
  4. Movement IV
  5. Movement V

Andy

Born from the fire of metal and fueled by the raw energy of punk, I live and breathe the music that defines us. With years of immersion in the scene, I've seen it all - from the underground gigs that shake the walls to the festival anthems that unite us all. As a relentless supporter of the scene, I’m here to give voice to the stories that matter. My words and interviews dig deep into the heart of the music, unearthing the grit, the glory, and the spirit that keeps metal and punk alive. Whether I'm dissecting the latest riffs or diving into the business behind the bands, my writing is as bold, direct, and relentless as the music itself. If you’re as passionate about this world as I am, my work is for you.

Learn More →