Gates of Kiev – “Gates of Kiev”

Four tracks, around forty minutes and a great deal of playing. On paper, a Dutch trio reviving the organ-driven excesses of 1970s progressive rock sounds like something I ought to enjoy. In practice, Gates of Kiev have given me an album that feels far more rewarding for the musicians performing it than for the person listening. I recognise the ability involved. I just wish I could say I enjoyed the songs.

The band were founded in the Netherlands by childhood friends Tomas Mesman, on keyboards and vocals, and drummer Hessel Braat. Bassist Eszl de Vois completed the trio after they met on the Amsterdam music scene. The name comes from their admiration for Emerson, Lake & Palmer, particularly the music on “Pictures at an Exhibition”. That lineage is no great surprise. You could take one look at the influences and make a fairly accurate prediction about where this record is heading.

There is nothing wrong with drawing heavily on the past. I have just given considerable praise to other artists for doing precisely that. Nor is there anything wrong with extended instrumental music. Some of my favourite musical experiences have involved bands allowing compositions to unfold over ten or fifteen minutes. But the important word is compositions. Length and complexity are not achievements in themselves. Something still has to happen that makes the journey worthwhile.

To be fair, these musicians can play. Mesman is clearly comfortable working with the prominent organ and keyboard arrangements, de Vois has the ability to move through the band’s progressive and jazz-influenced ideas, and Braat provides the rhythmic foundation for music that rarely takes a straightforward route. I have no particular quarrel with the instrumental competence. In fact, I think that is what makes my disappointment more pronounced.

The problem is that the four tracks strike me as exercises in self-indulgence rather than fully convincing pieces of songwriting. There are ideas, flourishes and changes of direction, certainly, but I never felt that those ideas were being developed into something I wanted to hear again. It is the sort of music that must be tremendous fun to work through in a rehearsal room. Listening to an entire album of it is another matter.

The opening “Hamlet Burns” runs to almost thirteen minutes, an ambitious introduction by any standard. The band describe it as a journey through loss and transformation, inspired by a Dutch winter landscape. I can respect that intention without finding the finished composition compelling. At that length, I want a sense of direction and a reason to invest in every successive passage. Instead, I found myself increasingly aware of how long I had been listening.

The same frustration follows me through “Baltazar’s Feast”, the comparatively concise “Silhouette” and the closing “Drunkship Of The Mice”. The themes and arrangements may differ, but none changed my overall impression. I kept waiting for the moment when an interesting idea became a great song. For me, it simply never arrived. Even “Silhouette”, at a little over six minutes, did not provide the focus I was looking for.

I also struggled with the sound of the finished recording. The band produced the album themselves, with Ahmad Mansour engineering and Jacob Holm-Lupo handling the mixing and mastering. Those are legitimate recording credits, and I would not question anyone’s competence on the basis of my personal reaction. Nevertheless, the overall presentation sounds strangely amateurish to my ears. Rather than bringing the numerous instrumental layers into a satisfying whole, it reinforces my impression of an album that needed a firmer hand in deciding which ideas worked and which did not.

There is a tendency, particularly with progressive rock, to treat every criticism of an extended composition as proof that the listener simply does not understand it. I do not accept that. Experimental music can be difficult, surprising and even uncomfortable while remaining utterly compelling. My objection here is not that Gates of Kiev are attempting something ambitious. It is that I find the outcome disjointed and ultimately rather dull.

Perhaps listeners with a deeper affection for the most extravagant corners of seventies progressive rock will find much more to celebrate. I can certainly imagine the band’s energy and musical interplay working better in a small, enthusiastic live venue. And I have no reason to doubt their sincerity or commitment to the music. But reviewing a record means judging the experience it provides, not the enjoyment its creators had making it.

Ultimately, “Gates of Kiev” is a showcase for capable players that, for me, never becomes a satisfying album. The seventies influences are obvious, the performances are competent and the ambition is undeniable. What is missing is the sense of purpose and memorable songwriting that might have justified spending forty minutes with these four pieces. A little less indulgence and rather more restraint could make all the difference next time. As it stands, this one really is not for me.

Rating: 4/10

Release Date: 2nd October 2026

Label: The Laser’s Edge

Writer: Andy

Tracklist:

  1. Hamlet Burns
  2. Baltazar’s Feast
  3. Silhouette
  4. Drunkship Of The Mice

Andy

Born from the fire of metal and fueled by the raw energy of punk, I live and breathe the music that defines us. With years of immersion in the scene, I've seen it all - from the underground gigs that shake the walls to the festival anthems that unite us all. As a relentless supporter of the scene, I’m here to give voice to the stories that matter. My words and interviews dig deep into the heart of the music, unearthing the grit, the glory, and the spirit that keeps metal and punk alive. Whether I'm dissecting the latest riffs or diving into the business behind the bands, my writing is as bold, direct, and relentless as the music itself. If you’re as passionate about this world as I am, my work is for you.

Learn More →